Is athena the best approach to connect to AWS Glue Catalog and fetch S3 data from .net client?

0

Hi, We are exploring approaches that would allow us to fetch data from S3 via AWS Glue Catalog from a .net client. We have already seen there is .net SDK available and it has athena client support. But are there any other alternative approaches too for .net clients? What are the pros and cons of this approach? We are thinking to use this as a reference https://davidpallmann.hashnode.dev/hello-athena

Regards

1 Answer
0

Good day.

From your case correspondence, I understand that you want to know Whether Amazon Athena is the best method for connecting to the AWS Glue Catalog and retrieving S3 data from a.Net client.

Amazon Athena is indeed a popular approach for querying data stored in Amazon S3 using standard SQL queries. It provides an interactive query service that allows you to analyze data directly from the AWS Glue Data Catalog, which acts as the metadata repository for your data assets.

When it comes to connecting to the AWS Glue catalog and fetching S3 data from a .NET client, there are multiple options available, and the "best" approach depends on your specific requirements and preferences. Here are a few factors to consider when evaluating the best approach:

Query Complexity: If your use case involves running complex SQL queries on large datasets, Amazon Athena's distributed and serverless nature can be beneficial. It automatically scales to handle large workloads and offers optimizations for query performance. However, if your requirements involve simple queries or data retrieval operations, using Athena might be overkill.

Real-time Data Access: If you need real-time access to data or require frequent updates, Athena may not be the most suitable choice. It is designed for batch-style processing and works best with static or infrequently updated data. In such cases, considering other options like AWS Glue ETL jobs or direct S3 access might be more appropriate.

Integration Complexity: Using the AWS SDK for .NET allows you to have more fine-grained control and flexibility in your application. You can utilize the SDK to interact with the Glue catalog, execute Athena queries, and retrieve results. However, this approach requires more development effort and knowledge of AWS services.

In summary, Amazon Athena can be a suitable approach for connecting to the AWS Glue catalog and fetching S3 data, especially for complex querying scenarios. However, it's important to evaluate your specific requirements, such as query complexity, real-time data access, integration complexity, and developer preferences, to determine the most appropriate approach for your .NET client.

I hope the above mentioned information serves helpful to you. Please let me know if you have any further queries related to the case. I will be more than happy to help.

answered a year ago
  • Thanks for your detailed answer. Our query to Athena/S3 will be directed from front-end so the response needs to be available fairly soon (possibly within few milliseconds). However, I think the data catalog is well partitioned on date basis. How soon can Athena return the response in this condition (I do understand it depends on amount of data but any rough estimates would be good)?

You are not logged in. Log in to post an answer.

A good answer clearly answers the question and provides constructive feedback and encourages professional growth in the question asker.

Guidelines for Answering Questions