Cannot add Amazon WorkMail for a domain

Hi,

I have a domain that I bought through Route 53 back in early July and I'm trying to add Amazon WorkMail to it. When I click "Manage Domains" on the WorkMail Org, I see my domain with status stuck in "Pending Verification". If I click into that, I see the following at the top of the page:

Amazon Route 53 hosted zone is not configured correctly
Your Route 53 hosted zone  for this domain needs to be set as authoritative. To learn how to set a hosted zone as authoritative, see Migrating DNS  in the AWS Route 53 Developer Guide.

Below it is a list of records it suggests I need to add. I did copy all those and add them to a new hosted zone I created myself (there was no default Hosted Zone with the - HostedZone created by Route53 Registrar description)

I see no option to hit the "Update all in Route 53" that I've done for other domains.

But I still see the same Amazon Route 53 hosted zone is not configured correctly message.

I have other domains that don't have the same problem.

Any ideas? Thanks